• No immunity for MPs, MLAs taking bribe to vote, make speech in House: SC

    National
    No immunity for MPs, MLAs taking bribe to vote, make speech in House: SC
    The Supreme Court ruled that bribery and corruption among lawmakers undermine the effectiveness of India's parliamentary democracy.

    Digital Desk: An MLA or MP cannot assert immunity from prosecution on an allegation of bribery related to a vote or statement in the Parliament or Legislative Assembly, according to a ruling made on Monday by a seven-judge Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court. The Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court unanimously overturned the 1998 ruling in the PV Narasimha Rao case.

    "We are not in agreement with the ruling in the PV Narasimha case, which shields lawmakers from being held accountable for alleged bribery for casting a vote or making a speech in the House that has broad implications," Chief Justice DY Chandrachud stated during the hearing.

    The Supreme Court ruled that bribery and corruption among lawmakers undermine the effectiveness of India's parliamentary democracy. Citing Article 105 or 194, the bench led by the Chief Justice stated that the bribery is not immune. 

    "A member indulging in bribery indulges in a criminal act which is not essential for casting a vote or giving a speech in the legislature," the CJI  ruled.

    The Supreme Court stated that Articles 105 and 194 of the Constitution are violated by the way the PV Narasimha ruling is interpreted. The court stated that the way the matter has been interpreted and the majority ruling in PV Narasimha Rao led to a paradoxical situation where a legislator receives immunity for accepting a bribe and then votes in the agreed-upon manner.

    The CJI further stated that the interpretation of the PV Narasimha ruling conflicts with Articles 105 and 194. Chief Justice Chandrachud went on to say that accepting an illicit bribe crystallizes the offense; it doesn't matter if the vote or speech is delivered thereafter.

    Speaking on the decision, Advocate Ashwini Upadhyay stated that the Supreme Court's ruling made it clear that if any legislator takes bribes to ask questions or cast votes in the legislature will not be immune to prosecution. He declared that the legislator in question would face corruption charges instead of any preferential treatment.

    "The Supreme Court ruled that asking questions or casting votes by taking bribes will be equivalent to destroying India's parliamentary democracy," stated the lawyer. 

     After hearing the arguments, a seven-judge panel led by the Chief Justice of India in October reserved a decision. Justices AS Bopanna, MM Sundresh, PS Narasimha, JB Pardiwala, Sanjay Kumar, and Manoj Misra are additional justices on the bench.

    A five-judge bench had previously noted that the problem was crucial and had a big impact on the morals of politics, thus it was referred to a bigger bench of seven judges to address.

    The court stated that the goal of Articles 105(2) and 194(2) is to guarantee that legislators in state legislatures and the parliament can carry out their duties in a free and unrestricted manner without fear of consequences.

    live casino onlinesabung ayam onlinelive baccaratsipardikemenaglebongtppkk bitunggs hospitalsarwadharma hospital gwltamansari mahoganypeasant farmersppdb yayasan pendidikan assalamgoji berryhttps://www.undp.or.id/https://mtsmathlaulanwarputat.sch.id/https://www.smpn2karangsambung.sch.id/https://hydrateivbar.com/https://hotelmiradordelsella.com/https://www.adamcopharm.com/https://ociterrasus.com/https://psb.al-asyariyyah.com/live casinodpd ipai jatimhttps://yplppgrikabbogor.com/https://smkveterancirebon.sch.id/https://www.min2jember.sch.id/https://sditfatahillahskh.sch.id/https://ichisultra.or.id/https://banggaiemas.org/https://pdamagam.co.id/https://akm.sdntambung2.sch.id/https://www.man1acehbarat.sch.id/https://lib.stishusnulkhotimah.ac.id/https://www.stieyapismerauke.ac.id/https://yayasanpendidikanassalam.sch.id/smp/vendor/https://www.undp.or.id/dunia-bola/https://www.undp.or.id/masa-depan/live casinosabung ayam onlinelive casino onlineagen bola onlineslot onlinelive casino onlinesabung ayam onlinesbobetagen casinoagen bolasabung ayam onlinesabung ayam onlineagen bolalive casino onlinesabung ayam onlineagen bola onlineslot qrisBANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303ASIANBET77/a>ASIANBET77ASIANBET77ASIANBET77ASIANBET77/a>ASIANBET77ASIANBET77ASIANBET77marianoserra.netmarianoserra.netpandawaputramakasar.compandawaputramakasar.comINDOAGEN188 INDOAGEN188INDOAGEN188INDOAGEN188sabung ayam onlinelive casino onlineagen bola onlinelive casino onlinesabung ayam onlineslot zeusagen bola onlinesabung ayam onlineSABUNG AYAM ONLINESBOBET88LIVE CASINO ONLINEINDOBOLA77SABUNG AYAM ONLINEMAHJONG WAYS 2SBOBETSV388INDOBOLA77LIVE CASINO ONLINESBOBET MIX PARLAYSABUNG AYAM ONLINEsabung ayamsbobet88live casinoslot onlinekalimantannews19.comkalimantannews19.comkalimantannews19.comkalimantannews19.comINDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88Live Casino OnlineSlot88Slot DanaAgen Judi Bola OnlineSlot Gacor 777Slot ThailandSlot GacorSlot Danaagen togel onlinebandar togel onlinesitus togel terpercayabandar togel terpercayaSV388LIVE CASINO ONLINESLOT KAKEK ZEUSSBOBET88SV388AGEN LIVE CASINO ONLINESITUS SLOT GACOR MAHJONG WAYS SCATTER HITAMAGEN SABUNG AYAM ONLINE WALA MERON SV388SBOBET88 LINK ALTERNATIF SBOBET AGEN JUDI BOLA ONLINE MIX PARLAY togel hongkonglive casino onlinebaccarat onlineasian handicapsitus sabung ayam onlineindojawa88indojawa88indojawa88Sabung Ayam Online LiveINDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88INDOMASTER88SBOBET88 LINK ALTERNATIF SBOBET AGEN JUDI BOLA ONLINE MIX PARLAY AGEN LIVE CASINO ONLINEAGEN SABUNG AYAM ONLINE WALA MERON SV388LIVE DRAW HK TOGEL HONGKONGhttps://carisma.co.id/page/https://carisma.co.id/lib/https://carisma.co.id/backup/SV388Mahjong Ways 2BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303owlzo.comowlzo.comowlzo.comowlzo.comeifu-test.virtualvox.com/a>eifu-test.virtualvox.comeifu-test.virtualvox.comeifu-test.virtualvox.comxvelopers.comkingaziz.id/a>kingaziz.idkingaziz.idkingaziz.idBANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303BANDAR303SV388optiflexcalculators.comoptiflexcalculators.comoptiflexcalculators.comoptiflexcalculators.comsabung ayam onlinelive casino onlinesitus togel onlineagen bola onlinesitus sabung ayam onlinelive casino onlinesabung ayam onlinecasino onlinetaruhan baccarat uang aslisv388sabung ayam onlinejudi bola onlinetogel hongkongagen live casinobandar sabung ayambandar togel onlineSV388LIVE CASINO ONLINESLOT MAHJONG WAYSSBOBET88http://siakad-sttbi.logiaedu.com/lib/http://siakad-sttbi.logiaedu.com/vendor/http://siakad-sttbi.logiaedu.com/app/http://siakad-sttbi.logiaedu.com/file/slot danasv388LIVE CASINO ONLINESABUNG AYAM ONLINESLOT ZEUS OLYMPUSMAHJONG WINS 3SV388SBOBETBACCARAT ONLINEsmaadventcimindi.sch.idsmaadventcimindi.sch.idsmaadventcimindi.sch.idsmaadventcimindi.sch.idpattniworld.comserviciosfunerariosmadrid.esdatosmadridgc.comsabung ayam onlineagen bola onlinelive casino onlineagen judi bolasabung ayam onlineagen taruhan bolahttps://webzsparkle.com/